In 2019, jemele hill wrote a controversial article for the atlantic titled, its time for black athletes. The financial implications of paying college athletes by. Critics of the idea insist that college athletes are students first, with athletics merely an extracurricular. Catalano 1 matthew catalano instructor ryan enc 1102 11 february 2017 finding common ground. Andrew yang says the ncaa is exploiting college athletes and is one of many who think the government will have to play a role in overhauling the current model. College athletes play as hard as they can to help their college win and return, they have to pay to play for them. Jul 18, 2011 if the student as athlete can find a way, heshe should be able to endorse products, to have paid speaking gigs, to sell memorabilia, as allen sack, the author and professor at the college of. The biggest reason why college athletes should not be paid is that having a scholarship is technically a form of pay. Observers also differ over whether colleges could afford salaries for players.
The astronomical amount of money generated by college athletics is. Just like nonathletes will get paid for their work when they graduate. May 06, 2014 if universities paid college athletes, the disparity between large and small university athletic teams would widen, like expecting the houston astros to compete on a level playing field with the. It would culminate into a situation where the only motive the athletes have for playing is money and not the sportsman drive of winning games and trophies. Gavin newsom on monday signed fair pay to play act, which will allow student athletes to get paid for the use of their name, image and likeness.
Feb 09, 2018 in an interview ahead of the publication of his new book, court justice, ed obannon discusses the reality of the studentathlete experience, why college athletes should be able to earn money and. In an interview ahead of the publication of his new book, court justice, ed obannon discusses the reality of the studentathlete experience, why college athletes should be able to earn money and. Each year, the issue of athletes being paid becomes more and more popular, so it is time to. Robbing college athletes under the guise of amateurism, raised a lot of questions about the ncaa and how the money is handled. And a 2017 washington post poll found that 2 in 3 respondents feel athletes should be paid when their name or image is used in video games or to sell merchandise.
This article would not have been possible without the work of. Finally, amid an ongoing debate about whether to pay college athletes, someone is pointing out that in fact they are compensatedtaxfree. This article is brought to you for free and open access by the student publications and. But if student athletes start being paid, then the question becomes why schools should even bother with the student part. If salaries were to replace scholarships in college sports, athletes would not. You can use the information in an argument essay on this topic.
Meanwhile, the revenues generated by college sports keep increasing. Though a dream for many, only about 7% of high school athletes move onto the bigger stage. The best football and basketball players in the big ten have produced to the degree that a television network has. Mar 29, 2017 race isnt the only issue, but statistically it plays a huge part in the reason why many people oppose the fact that college athletes should be getting paid. A way to start paying college athletes the new york times. This article analyzes the current state of college athletics, considering. But while some, including many coaches, are making small fortunes off of college sports, compensation for one group is meticulously limited. Perhaps its because of the current economic climate and everyone, including amateur athletes is looking for ways to make money.
Athletes could be paid under new california law the. These athletes are doing the same things as pros, but are not payed a penny. For example, the selected proceedings, which can be found at law. No, the athlete does not get that money to spend on whatever they want, but the most important thing is paid for.
College athletes have a long way to go before they can get compensated in any way. Its that simple, and as a current student athlete myself, i couldnt be more comfortable saying that. The first, and most often forgotten, aspect of compensating. What has continued to be one of the most pressing issues in the world of sports today has now become a matter the. Should athletes be paid for college athletes 984 words 4 pages. Write the information you find on a piece of paper.
Apr 26, 2016 on the other hand, some college athletes in football, basketball, hockey, and baseball also have the opportunity to reap handsome rewards for their collegiate careers if they succeed in getting to the professional level, and those who take full advantage of their academic opportunities certainly can take with them a valuable college degree. It presents various proposed reforms, including the national collegiate athletic as. July 15, 20 mike gilleran a discussion forum institute of sports law and ethics, santa clara university. Ncaa plans to allow college athletes to get paid for use. And yet i believe that the drive to pay college athletes is a grave mistakenot because it misdiagnoses the disease but because it. College studentathletes are given a rare opportunity. Pdf the exploitation ofcollege athletes, particularly black revenue athletes, has. Gavin newsom acknowledges he is picking a fight and he thinks hell win. College athletes should be paid essay 1596 words bartleby. With the pressure to succeed, should college student athletes be paid. The continued exploitation of the college athlete core. The ncaa disagrees with the petition, arguing that student athletes. Jul 18, 2016 the biggest reason why college athletes should not be paid is that having a scholarship is technically a form of pay. This week, college football players at northwestern university petitioned the national labor relations board to form a union.
Certainly those numbers, plus the cost of tuition, room, and board, are not minor, but they are relatively small when. Supporters of the system say the education and training athletes receive are adequate compensation. Its difficult to earn a position on a college team. The best college athletes in the two revenueproducing sports have always been worth much more than tuition, room, board and books. The average college student would kill to have their school already paid for.
Mar 25, 2018 college athletes in injuryprone sports are risking their longterm health and wellbeing. Leveling the field for college athletes western center. Find arguments in the article that support each side of this debate. The college football championship shows how much money flows to successful coaches and schools but not to the players. If the student as athlete can find a way, heshe should be able to endorse products, to have paid speaking gigs, to sell memorabilia, as allen sack, the author and professor at the college of. Theres no reason they should get a paycheck on top of that. Arguments against paying athletes should manziel get paid. In addition, schools also argue that student athletes are amateurs15 and, therefore, are not entitled to be paid. Many athletes graduate without a dime of debt at a time when the majority of college students are burdened by loans just as they are launching their careers. Another 2% of these athletes reach the division i level, reports dave anderson in his article top 10 reasons college athletes should not be paid. If youre getting paid for playing a sport in college, what motivation do you have to do well in school or work toward getting drafted. Student athletes should get paid, college students say. Ncaa plans to allow college athletes to get paid for use of their names, images the organization says its just starting to work out the details of how athletes would be.
See lee goldman, sports and antitrust should college students be paid to play. This article is brought to you for free and open access by the journals at marquette law. This article will begin by addressing the background of the ncaas amateurism regulation and the current financial state of the ncaa. S colleges and universities operate largescale commercial athletic programs, with a focus on mens football and basketball. A discussion forum institute of sports law and ethics, santa clara university preface the institute of sports law and ethics isle has a strong focus on the ethical aspects of sports. The book was an argumentative book about athletes getting paid before the big leagues. In addition, schools also argue that studentathletes are amateurs15 and, therefore, are not entitled to be paid. There was a particular focus on the issue of whether college athletes should be paid. Introduction this article analyzes the current state of college athletics, considering its commercialization and exploitation of the studentathlete. California governor signs law allowing college athletes to. Practical acknowledgement of the long odds of making it to the pros. Some lawmakers, and a presidential candidate, say yes. After all, shouldnt you have something to work toward.
Three reasons why college athletes should not get paid. Pick a wordlinepassage from the article and respond to it. The california bill is not about paying athletes, but rather about clearing an avenue through which. Critics and plaintiffs lawyers say students who play sports should be paid salaries. Sep 20, 2018 the ncaa says paying athletes hurts their education. People who believe that college athletes should not be paid often point out that professional athletes in the major sports can make millions of dollars. The ncaa says paying athletes hurts their education. Appearing in the magazine, it was headlined lets start paying college athletes. Gavin newsom signed a bill to allow college athletes to hire agents and make.
Paying ncaa athletes marquette law scholarly commons. Next, the article addresses the threshold argument regarding whether college athletes deserve compensation in addition to athletic scholarships. A practical approach to paying college athletes seattle university. Sep 11, 2019 an overwhelming 80% of all students and 83% of athletes agreed that college athletes should be paid if their image is used for purposes such as selling merchandise. In september, 2012, isle presented its third annual symposium, the role of sports in higher. The difference for college athletes is marginal in term of money. Paying college athletes would remove their competitive nature and the passion they have for the games they participate in.
With the signing of californias fair pay to play act, gov. There are several persuasive arguments as to why college athletes should be paid, but those. Colleges and ncaa sports are already awkward bedfellows. Feb 06, 2015 in addition to exploring the labor market for college athletes, the paper, entitled the case for paying college athletes also examines why u. Ncaa plans to allow college athletes to get paid for use of their names, images the organization says its just starting to work out the details of how athletes would be compensated. How much revenue should be paid to the athletes who the.
Ncaa studentathletes is the decision of who will be getting paid. Read about how the law known as the fair pay to play act came together, and get some answers to key questions. Siegfried the and collegiate 21st media century athletic dollars has association been have both never the ncaa been best higher, and and worst its owing members. Student athletes already have a head start on regular students who have to pay for their own university classes. The intensity of the argument to pay college athletes has escalated in the past few years. Should college athletes be paid download ebook pdf, epub. This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want. Should college athletes get paid if it means that institutions of higher learning will need to operate more like professional sports franchises than schools. California wants its college athletes to get paid, but the. There were a lot of good points from many different people in this book. If payments were involved, athletes would be given incentive to commit to the college or university with the highest offer. Nov 23, 2017 reasons why college athletes should not be paid. In a ruling on march 26, a regional director of the national labor relations board in chicago said that football players at northwestern university were employees of the private school and therefore had the right to unionize, setting up the possibility of the first labor union in college sports.
Its only intensified as the national collegiate athletics association ncaa has seen revenues soar in recent years. Click download or read online button to get should college athletes be paid book now. In an interview ahead of the publication of his new book, court justice, ed obannon discusses the reality of the studentathlete experience, why college athletes should be. In discussions of compensation for college athletes, a particular point of disagreement has been weather or not college athletes should be paid for their hard work. It has been decades since people have been asking, should college athletes get paid. The idea of paying college athletes is certainly not a new one though yang does have a specific plan. Rather than call the athletes competing on the field workers, colleges and universities utilize the term studentathlete. It does include protections to prevent college athletes from becoming ineligible to play in ncaa competitions. Based on how the ncaa has evolved over time and the amount of income they generate, college athletes should get paid for the time that they put into their respective sports. Jan 09, 2016 i wrote my first article for the new york times about the n.
The debate over whether college athletes should be paid for their services has existed for decades. To that extent, the ncaa has recently allowed schools to pay for the full cost of school attendance transportation and living expenses that were not covered by scholarships by college athletes. College athletics is a multibilliondollar industry that continues to grow each year. College athletes are used to create a billion dollar business, industries rely on them constantly working away and receive little to no compensation. I chose the book should college athletes be paid because it was seemed like an interesting book to read. Sep 10, 2018 in conclusion, almost anyone who is involved with sports, whether it be watching them or playing them, has an opinion on whether college athletes should be paid. What makes us any different than any other student. College athletes should be paid because they play the same game as pros and pros are paid. There are several objections to the argument of paying college athletes, and the common ones are as follows. To be eligible to play ncaa sports, players must maintain amateur status, which means they cant be paid for participating.
Oklahoma city thunder star forward carmelo anthony met with reporters on tuesday afternoon to discuss whether athletes should get paid in college sports as. Collegiate athletics at the division i level is a big business. An overwhelming 80% of all students and 83% of athletes agreed that college athletes should be paid if their image is used for purposes such as selling merchandise. One major finding was about the fair market value of an average fbs football and basketball player. Simply put, the law provides a path for collegiate athletes who already make money for their schools and for the ncaa to be paid some of that money as well leveling the playing field for those out there on the field.
276 128 65 748 1423 4 382 1250 1529 278 317 839 200 1363 266 723 937 140 328 1063 1605 1303 377 497 783 557 1143 1580 1007 180 171 246 728 1224 1386 861 1032 715 649 271 1469